Most will contests fail, and they usually fail for the same reason: the family members who bring them are certain something improper happened, but merely believing something with certainty is not evidence. In October 2026, the New Jersey Appellate Division decided two will contests within a week of each other. The families, the facts, and the legal theories were different. The outcomes were identical — both wills stood, and both contests were thrown out before trial. Read together, the two cases are a practical guide to what New Jersey courts actually require before they set aside a will.
What You Have to Prove
A will that has been admitted to probate starts with the presumption that it is valid and that the person who signed it was of sound mind. The burden of proof sits on the person challenging it.
The most common ground is undue influence. New Jersey defines it as a "mental, moral, or physical exertion of a kind and quality that destroys the free will of the testator by preventing that person from following the dictates of his or her own mind as it relates to the disposition of assets." Ordinary persuasion, affection, or even pestering is not enough. The influence has to overpower the testator's own wishes and substitute someone else's.
There is one important exception to who carries the burden. If the will benefits someone who stood in a "confidential relationship" with the testator — a relationship of trust and dependence, not just closeness — and there are also "suspicious circumstances" surrounding the will, the burden shifts to the beneficiary to prove there was no undue influence. The evidence of suspicious circumstances only needs to be slight, but there has to be some. A drastic, unexplained change in how the estate is divided can qualify. As the two cases below show, though, contestants routinely lose on the first element: proving the confidential relationship.
The Caregiver Daughter: The Estate of Schneider
Joanne Schneider's 1996 will divided her estate equally among her four children. Her daughter Deborah had been her caregiver since 1996 and lived in the family home, helping with household tasks and taking her to medical appointments. In 2015, Joanne's two sons got into an altercation with their brother-in-law, and their relationship with their mother deteriorated badly. Eleven months later, Joanne signed a new will that disinherited both sons and named Deborah as sole executor. She later retitled an investment account so that Deborah would receive seventy-five percent of it on her death and her other daughter, Jennifer, the remaining twenty-five percent. The sons pointed to a 2021 Adult Protective Services investigation — which noted that Joanne suffered from dementia, though it did not substantiate financial exploitation — as proof that something was wrong.
After Joanne died in 2024, the sons contested the 2016 will, arguing that Deborah and Jennifer had unduly influenced their mother and that the burden of proof should shift to the daughters. The trial court disagreed, and on October 16, 2026, the Appellate Division affirmed in In re Estate of Joanne W. Schneider.
The court's reasoning is the part anyone considering a contest should read carefully. Family ties and caregiving, standing alone, do not create a confidential relationship. What the record showed, the court said, was "the ordinary relationship between a mother and her daughters." There was no evidence that either daughter dominated Joanne or that Joanne depended on them in a way that compromised her free will — by all accounts she was strong-willed, understood her finances, and managed them herself. Nor was there any medical evidence that she lacked capacity in 2016, when the will was signed; the dementia noted by APS surfaced years later. And there were no suspicious circumstances: neither daughter arranged for the will or was present when it was discussed or signed, the same attorney drafted both the 1996 and 2016 wills, and the change itself had an obvious explanation — a mother who had fallen out with her sons revised her estate plan to match. The burden never shifted, and the contest ended.
The $5 Million Provision That Disappeared: The Estate of DelGatto
The second case, In re Estate of Thomas DelGatto, Jr., decided October 21, 2026, added a theory the Schneider case did not have: fraud.
Thomas DelGatto held a fifty-percent interest in the family business behind the Westmount Country Club. His February 2018 will contained a provision leaving $5 million, to be divided among his father's grandchildren — at the time, his nieces and nephew — if his stock was sold for more than $9 million after his death. He renewed that provision in a February 2021 will. Thomas had been diagnosed with pancreatic cancer in 2020, and by early 2021 his relationship with his father had reached what his own lawyer described as a breaking point. In March 2021 he directed his attorney to replace his father with his wife, Kristen, as executor and trustee. The will he signed on June 10, 2021 went further: it also eliminated the $5 million grandchildren provision entirely, leaving his estate to Kristen and their two young daughters. Kristen had taken no part in his estate planning and had never even met his attorney until after Thomas died. His own text messages confirmed the design: his wife "has power of attorney of everything and calls all the shots," and his father was "not permitted to change anything."
After Thomas died in May 2022, the nieces and nephew sued. They claimed Kristen had unduly influenced him, and that his attorney had removed the $5 million provision without his knowledge — an equitable fraud claim. The trial court granted Kristen summary judgment, and the Appellate Division affirmed on every point.
On undue influence, the court emphasized a rule that surprises many people: no presumption of undue influence arises when one spouse makes a will in the other's favor, and courts are "extremely hesitant" to shift the burden of proof to a spouse. There was no evidence Kristen dominated Thomas, participated in the planning, or even knew what the will said. And the change was not suspicious. As the trial judge put it, everything Thomas did made sense for a dying man with a wife and two small children: he left more to the natural objects of his bounty and cut out a provision entangled with the father he no longer trusted.
On fraud, the claim collapsed on the evidence. Fraud is never presumed; it must be proven by clear and convincing evidence. The attorney certified that Thomas personally directed him to remove the provision. Against that, the contestants offered the fact that an earlier draft still contained it and that a witness did not see Thomas read the final will before signing — which the court characterized as speculation, not proof. The court also rejected the argument that Thomas's "probable intent" still favored the grandchildren: read against his final year of life, his most recent intent was plainly to remove them.
One part of the case went the contestants' way, and it matters. Even though they lost, the trial court ordered the estate to pay their legal fees — $329,445.40 in fees and $23,887.61 in costs — and the Appellate Division upheld the award. Under Rule 4:42-9(a)(3), when a contestant had "reasonable cause" for challenging a will, the court may pay both sides' fees out of the estate. A provision that appeared in two earlier wills and vanished from the third was enough to make the challenge reasonable, win or lose.
What These Cases Mean in Practice
A few lessons run through both decisions, and they match what I see whenever a family asks me about contesting a will.
Being cut out of a will is not, by itself, a case. Neither is the fact that the beneficiary was a caregiver, held a power of attorney, or was simply closer to the parent than you were. Courts look for proof that the testator was dominated — dependent on the beneficiary in a way that destroyed independent decision-making — and for circumstances around the signing that genuinely call for explanation. Contemporaneous medical evidence matters enormously: in Schneider, the absence of any medical proof from the year the will was signed was fatal, and later evidence of dementia could not fill the gap. A will change that follows a family falling-out or a terminal diagnosis, and that favors a spouse and young children, will usually be treated as an explanation, not a red flag. And as DelGatto shows, accusing the drafting attorney of secretly changing a will requires proof approaching certainty, not inference piled on inference.
The fee ruling in DelGatto cuts in both directions. It protects a family member who challenges a will on reasonable grounds from being ruined by the cost of asking legitimate questions. But it also means an estate can spend hundreds of thousands of dollars defending a will that was valid all along — money that comes out of what the beneficiaries ultimately receive. I wrote about a different kind of expensive will fight in my post on estate planning lessons from a New Jersey Supreme Court will dispute, and some estate disputes can even be pushed out of court entirely, as I explained in my post on arbitrating an estate dispute.
If you believe a will does not reflect what your loved one actually wanted, timing matters as much as proof. A challenge begins with a caveat filed with the Surrogate before the will is admitted to probate, and waiting can narrow your options considerably. Talk to an attorney before you assume that an unfair result is also an unlawful one — these two cases show how wide the gap between the two can be. And if you are making your own estate plan, the best protection against a contest is a will that is current, clearly drafted, and consistent with your circumstances, which is why I recommend reviewing the basics of a last will and testament whenever your family situation changes.
If you have attended a free dinner seminar on estate planning, you have heard the pitch. Probate is a nightmare, the government is coming for your house, and the only thing standing between your family and financial ruin is a revocable living trust — available tonight at a special seminar price.
Here is the honest answer I give my clients: a revocable living trust is a genuinely useful tool, but in New Jersey it is oversold. Whether you need one depends entirely on your situation, and most of what the seminars claim is either exaggerated or flatly wrong.
What a Revocable Living Trust Actually Is
A revocable living trust is a legal arrangement you create during your lifetime. You transfer your assets — house, bank accounts, investments — into the trust and name yourself trustee. You keep complete control: you can spend the money, sell the property, change the terms, or revoke the whole thing whenever you want. Under N.J.S.A. 3B:31-43(a), a New Jersey trust is revocable unless its terms expressly say otherwise.
When you die, your chosen successor trustee steps in and distributes everything per your instructions, with no court proceeding for the assets actually in the trust. For income tax purposes, the IRS pretends the trust does not exist while you are alive — a revocable trust is a grantor trust, so all income is taxed to you exactly as if you still held everything in your own name.
Does a Revocable Trust Save You Meaningful Probate Costs in New Jersey?
The number one selling point is probate avoidance. In some states that warning has real teeth. In New Jersey, it mostly does not. I have written in detail about what probate actually looks like here: for a typical uncontested estate, it is an administrative process through the county Surrogate's Court, with typical government filing fees and costs, and no courtroom appearance required. Attorney fees are not set by a statutory percentage the way they are in California or Florida.
So when a trust is marketed to you mainly as New Jersey probate avoidance, ask what problem is actually being solved — for many families, that probate was never going to be expensive. Avoiding probate may have some value, but it is one benefit among several, and it should not be the whole sales pitch.
Does a Revocable Trust Save You Taxes?
This is where the seminar pitch falls apart for New Jersey residents. A revocable living trust does not reduce your taxes — not federal, not state.
New Jersey repealed its estate tax for individuals who died on or after January 1, 2018. There is nothing left for a trust to avoid. The New Jersey inheritance tax, on the other hand, is very much alive — and a revocable trust does nothing to escape it. Because you keep the power to revoke, the state treats the trust property as a transfer taking effect at your death, taxable under N.J.S.A. 54:34-1(c). The tax depends on who receives the assets, not on whether they passed through probate or a trust. Transfers to a spouse, children, parents, and other Class A beneficiaries are exempt either way; transfers to more distant relatives are taxed either way. The trust changes the mechanics, not the tax bill.
Does a Revocable Trust Protect Your Assets?
Because you can revoke the trust and take everything back at any time, your creditors can reach the assets too — a court can simply order you to revoke it. If creditor protection is your goal, a revocable trust provides none.
The same logic applies to Medicaid, and this is the version I see most often. New Jersey's Medicaid rules are explicit: for a revocable trust, the entire corpus counts as a resource available to you (N.J.A.C. 10:71-4.11(e)1.i). Every dollar in the trust counts toward the $2,000 resource limit. Putting your house into a revocable living trust does absolutely nothing for Medicaid eligibility. If sheltering assets from long-term care costs is the objective, that requires an irrevocable trust under completely different rules, including the five-year lookback.
What It Actually Does Well
With the myths cleared away, here is what the trust genuinely offers. First, privacy: probate is a public process and your will becomes a public record, while a trust is administered privately by your successor trustee. Second, out-of-state property: a Florida vacation home or Pennsylvania condo held in the trust avoids a separate probate proceeding in each of those states.
Third, incapacity planning. Your successor trustee can step in and manage trust assets without court involvement — but only for assets actually in the trust. Property left outside it may still require a guardianship proceeding, and a court-appointed guardian can, with court approval, exercise your powers over the trust itself. A trust is a strong incapacity tool, but it does not replace a durable power of attorney or healthcare documents. As noted above, it also does not help an incapacitated person qualify for long-term care Medicaid.
Fourth, control over distributions. You can keep a minor child's inheritance in trust until an age you choose, and in a blended family you can provide for a surviving spouse for life while preserving the remainder for your children. One caution: if a beneficiary has a disability and receives means-tested benefits, a standard revocable trust can disqualify them — that situation calls for a special needs trust, a different instrument.
The Step Everyone Skips: Funding the Trust
The failure I see more than any other: someone pays several thousand dollars for a beautiful trust document, takes it home, puts it in a drawer, and never funds it. A trust only controls the assets you actually transfer into it — the house needs a new deed, the accounts need retitling, and each transfer takes paperwork.
An unfunded trust is an expensive stack of paper. Assets left outside it go through probate exactly as if the trust did not exist, which means the client paid for probate avoidance and got probate anyway. If you create a trust, fund it promptly and completely, and review it whenever you acquire significant new assets. Treat funding as part of the engagement, not homework for later.
When I Tell Clients Yes — and When I Tell Them No
I recommend a revocable living trust without hesitation for clients who own real estate in another state, have strong privacy concerns, want incapacity planning beyond a power of attorney, have minor children with significant assets, or are navigating a blended family.
I talk clients out of one just as often. If your estate is straightforward — a New Jersey home, bank and investment accounts, everything going to your spouse and then your children — a well-drafted will, current beneficiary designations, and payable-on-death designations accomplish essentially everything a trust would, at a fraction of the cost. A properly drafted and funded trust typically runs several thousand dollars. Spending that to solve a problem you do not have is not planning.
The Bottom Line
A revocable living trust is a tool, not a magic wand that solves all potential problems. It does not cut your taxes, does not protect assets from creditors or Medicaid, and in New Jersey it does not buy the dramatic probate savings the seminars may advertise. What it does buy — privacy, control over distributions, incapacity planning, and multi-state simplicity — is genuinely valuable for the right family. The right question was never "should I get a living trust." It is "what problem am I trying to solve." If the answers involve privacy, out-of-state property, minor children, a blended/second family, or incapacity, a trust may be exactly right. If they involve taxes, asset protection, or fear of New Jersey probate, you are being sold a solution to a problem you do not have — and the documents you actually need are a current will, a durable power of attorney, a healthcare proxy, and a living will. Before you sign anything at a seminar, talk to an attorney who asks about your family first and reaches for a product second.
When Daniel's father was diagnosed with Parkinson's disease, Daniel cut back his hours at work and moved into the family home to care for him. He cooked meals, helped his father bathe and dress, drove him to medical appointments, and sat up with him on the bad nights. Every month, his father wrote him a check for $2,000. Nobody in the family thought twice about it. The care was real, the need was obvious, and the payment simply recognized what Daniel was giving up to provide it.
Two years later, Daniel's father entered a nursing home and applied for Medicaid. The county welfare agency pulled five years of bank statements, found $48,000 in checks written to Daniel, and treated every dollar as a gift. The result was a transfer penalty — months of Medicaid ineligibility imposed at the precise moment the family could least afford to pay for care privately.
This is one of the most punishing and most avoidable mistakes in Medicaid planning. New Jersey law does not prohibit paying a family member to provide care. But it does presume — aggressively — that money paid to a relative without a written agreement in place beforehand was a gift, not compensation. Overcoming that presumption after the fact is extraordinarily difficult. This post explains the rule, the presumption, and the written caregiver agreement that solves the problem.
Informal Payments Are Presumed Gifts
The governing New Jersey regulation, N.J.A.C. 10:71-4.10, contains a provision aimed squarely at this situation. It provides that when a transfer is "intended to compensate a friend or relative for care or services provided in the past," any care "provided for free at the time [it was] delivered shall be presumed to have been intended to be delivered without compensation." In plain terms: if no agreement to pay existed when the care was provided, the regulation treats the care as having been provided for free — and treats the later payment as a transfer for no compensation. N.J.A.C. 10:71-4.10(b)(6)(ii).
That presumption can be rebutted, but only with "credible documentary evidence preexisting the delivery of the care or services indicating the type and terms of compensation." Notice what that requires. The documentation must exist before the care begins, and it must spell out what the caregiver will do and what the caregiver will be paid. A handshake understanding, a family consensus, or a written agreement drafted a year into the arrangement does not satisfy this standard.
The regulation adds a second constraint that surprises many families: the compensation "shall not be greater than the prevailing rates for similar care or services in the community," and any amount above the prevailing rate "shall be considered to be uncompensated value." Simply agreeing to paying a daughter $500.00 an hour for companionship and light housekeeping does not make the payment legitimate — the amount above fair market value is treated as a gift regardless of what the family agreed to.
The Legal Framework Behind the Presumption
The federal statute, 42 U.S.C. § 1396p(c)(1)(A), requires state Medicaid plans to impose a period of ineligibility when an institutionalized individual "disposes of assets for less than fair market value" during the 60-month lookback period. New Jersey implements that mandate through N.J.A.C. 10:71-4.10, which adds a procedural feature families need to understand: every transfer within the lookback period is presumed to have been made to obtain earlier Medicaid eligibility than the applicant would otherwise be entitled to. N.J.A.C. 10:71-4.10(i).
The applicant can rebut that presumption, but the standard is demanding — "convincing evidence that the assets were transferred exclusively (that is, solely) for some other purpose." N.J.A.C. 10:71-4.10(j). "Exclusively" is doing heavy work in that sentence. If the county believes even part of the motivation was accelerating Medicaid eligibility, the rebuttal fails.
📊 Example Calculation: Take the $48,000 in undocumented caregiver payments from the opening scenario. Penalty Period = $48,000 ÷ $420.67 (New Jersey's daily penalty divisor, effective April 1, 2026) = approximately 114 days of Medicaid ineligibility. During those 114 days, the applicant must pay for long-term care entirely out of pocket — after already spending down to the $2,000 asset limit.
What a New Jersey Court Did With Documented and Undocumented Caregiver Payments
The distinction between documented compensation and undocumented transfers is not theoretical. In E.C. v. Division of Medical Assistance and Health Services, No. A-0832-17T4 (N.J. Super. Ct. App. Div. Mar. 25, 2019) (unpublished), a 103-year-old Medicaid applicant had paid a caretaker $150 per week in cash — $3,600 total — for housekeeping, meal preparation, bathing, and toileting assistance provided from December 2014 through May 2015. The administrative law judge found the caretaker's testimony about those services credible, and that $3,600 was excluded from the transfer penalty.
Everything else was penalized. Additional amounts the caretaker claimed to have spent on the applicant's behalf — groceries, household items, podiatrist visits — were treated as uncompensated transfers because no receipts were produced at the hearing. An affidavit submitted after the hearing, unsupported by bank records, was rejected as not credible. And $12,510 claimed for caretaking services provided after the applicant entered the nursing home was disallowed. The agency's director adopted the decision, and the Appellate Division affirmed.
The lesson of E.C. is blunt: New Jersey's system rewards documentation and punishes its absence. Credible, specific evidence of services actually performed at a reasonable rate survived. Approximations, after-the-fact affidavits, and payments for care the nursing facility was already providing did not.
A Written Caregiver Agreement
A caregiver agreement — sometimes called a personal care agreement or personal services contract — is a written contract between the person receiving care and the person (who may be a family member) providing it. When properly structured, it converts what the regulation would otherwise presume to be a gift into documented compensation for services at fair market value. The regulation itself tells you what the agreement must contain to survive scrutiny:
It must be in writing and signed before care begins. This is the single most important requirement. The regulation demands documentary evidence "preexisting the delivery of the care or services indicating the type and terms of compensation." An agreement drafted after months of caregiving cannot retroactively recharacterize free care as compensated care.
It must describe the specific services, schedule, and rate. The agreement should state what the caregiver will do (bathing, dressing, meal preparation, medication supervision, transportation, overnight supervision), how many hours per week, and the hourly rate. Vague descriptions invite the county to question whether the services were actually worth the payment.
The rate must not exceed prevailing community rates. The rate of pay cannot exceed fair market value. Whatever the rate agreed upon, it must be supportable — the portion above the prevailing rate is uncompensated value, dollar for dollar.
Payment should track the services as they are performed. Paying the caregiver on a regular schedule — weekly or biweekly, by check or traceable transfer — looks like compensation. A single lump-sum prepayment for years of future care looks like a transfer, and it invites the county to treat it as one.
The services must be real, needed, and documented. A care log recording the dates, hours, and tasks performed each week is the documentary backbone of the arrangement. It is also worth obtaining a physician's written statement that the person needs assistance with daily activities — while the regulation does not expressly require it, it substantially strengthens the "credible documentary evidence" the regulation calls for.
The caregiver should report the income. Payments under a caregiver agreement are generally taxable income to the caregiver. Reporting the income is both a tax obligation and further evidence that the arrangement was genuine compensation rather than a disguised gift. Consult a tax professional for the specifics.
Common Mistakes That Sink Caregiver Agreements
Even families who understand the concept routinely make errors that render their agreements worthless:
Backdating the agreement. An agreement signed today but dated six months ago — or drafted after the Medicaid application is already contemplated — fails the regulation's requirement that the documentation preexist the care. A backdated agreement is not a plan; it is evidence of the problem.
Lump-sum prepayment. Paying $60,000 up front for "three years of future care" asks the county to accept on faith that the services will be performed. Pay as the care is delivered.
Vague duties. "Assist as needed" does not establish what was done or how the payment was calculated. Define the tasks and schedule.
No care logs. A contract proves an agreement existed; it does not prove the caregiver actually performed 30 hours of work in a particular week. Keep contemporaneous records.
Above-market rates. The excess over the prevailing rate is uncompensated value by regulation, no matter what the family agreed to.
Cash with no paper trail. The E.C. case is the cautionary tale: the documented $3,600 survived; the undocumented amounts did not.
Paying for care the facility provides. Once the person is in a nursing home, paying a relative for the same personal care the facility is already delivering will not be treated as fair-market compensation, as E.C. demonstrates.
Final Thoughts
A caregiver agreement is one of the simplest documents in elder law and one of the most consequential. It costs little to prepare and it protects two things at once: it fairly compensates the family member who sacrifices time and income to provide care, and it prevents that compensation from being recharacterized as a gift that triggers months of Medicaid ineligibility. But the protection only exists if the agreement is in place before the first hour of care is delivered. Once the payments have been made without one, the regulation's presumption does the rest.
Many New Jersey families are surprised to learn that qualifying for Medicaid Long-Term Services and Supports (MLTSS) depends not only on income but also on how retirement assets are classified. A pension, IRA, 401(k), 403(b), annuity, or other retirement account can dramatically affect Medicaid eligibility, though not always in the way people expect. Understanding how these assets are treated is critical if you are planning for nursing home care, assisted living, or home-based long-term care through New Jersey's MLTSS program.
Understanding MLTSS Financial Eligibility
MLTSS is New Jersey's Medicaid program that helps pay for long-term care services in nursing homes, assisted living facilities, and at home. To qualify, an applicant must first meet the program's clinical (level-of-care) requirements and then satisfy both an income test and a resource (asset) test. For 2026, a single applicant generally may have no more than $2,982 per month in gross income and no more than $2,000 in countable resources. The income test and the resource test are separate issues and should not be confused with one another.
What Happens If Your Income Is Over the Medicaid Limit?
Medicaid requires applicants to disclose virtually all sources of income, including Social Security retirement benefits, pensions, IRA distributions, annuity payments, employment income, veterans' benefits, and other recurring payments.
Many people assume that earning more than the monthly income limit automatically disqualifies them from Medicaid. In New Jersey, that is not necessarily true. For individuals whose gross monthly income exceeds the limit, eligibility may still be achieved through a Qualified Income Trust (QIT), often called a Miller Trust. A QIT allows excess income to be deposited into a specially drafted trust account each month. As long as the trust is properly established and administered, the income deposited into it is generally not counted against the applicant for eligibility purposes.
This is particularly important for retirees who receive income from multiple sources, such as Social Security, pensions, and Required Minimum Distributions (RMDs) from retirement accounts. In many cases, individuals who appear financially ineligible at first glance can still qualify for MLTSS through proper use of a QIT. Read more about QITs here.
However, qualifying for Medicaid does not mean you keep all of your income. Once approved, most of the recipient's monthly income must generally be contributed toward the cost of care, subject to certain allowances and deductions. This amount is commonly referred to as the beneficiary's cost share or patient pay amount.
Because income calculations can be complex, especially when retirement accounts, spousal income, annuities, or trust distributions are involved, families should have their eligibility reviewed before assuming that excess income prevents them from qualifying.
Understanding the Resource Test
Countable resources generally include the principal balances of:
Checking and savings accounts
Certificates of deposit
Stocks and bonds
Investment accounts
Cash surrender value of certain life insurance policies
Real estate other than the principal residence
Retirement accounts
A second automobile
Some assets are exempt, including:
A primary residence in qualifying circumstances
One vehicle
Personal belongings
Irrevocable prepaid funeral arrangements
Certain burial funds
Are IRAs and 401(k)s in Payout Status Countable for NJ Medicaid?
The short answer is yes. Unlike some other states with more generous rules, New Jersey treats an IRA, 401(k), 403(b), or similar retirement account as a countable resource for Medicaid purposes, even if the account is in payout status. The account will usually have to be liquidated and spent down before eligibility can be established. This comes as a shock to many retirees, who assume these accounts are protected because they receive favorable tax treatment and shelter from certain creditors. That protection does not extend to Medicaid eligibility. Medicaid is a needs-based program, and the State expects applicants to use their own resources to pay for long-term care before the program steps in.
This is a separate issue from the income rules discussed above. Distributions from the account are generally treated as income, while the principal balance is treated as an available resource. As a result, even a single retirement account can affect both the resource limit and the income limit.
How Pensions Are Treated
Defined-benefit pensions are generally treated differently from retirement accounts holding an accumulated balance. A monthly pension payment is typically considered income rather than a resource. For example, if a retired teacher receives a $1,500 monthly pension, Medicaid generally views those payments as income. The pension itself is not an asset that can be liquidated and spent down in the way an IRA or 401(k) can. The same principle applies to Social Security retirement benefits and many government pensions.
Married Couples Receive More Protection
A single Medicaid applicant may have no more than $2,000 in countable resources. The rules are more complicated for married couples. When only one spouse requires long-term care, Medicaid is designed to prevent the healthy spouse, often called the "community spouse," from becoming impoverished. The community spouse is entitled to keep a portion of the couple's countable assets under the Community Spouse Resource Allowance (CSRA).
In 2026, the community spouse may retain up to $162,660 in countable resources, while the spouse applying for Medicaid remains limited to $2,000. Importantly, the CSRA is not based simply on whose name appears on an account. Medicaid looks at the couple's combined countable assets as of a "snapshot date" and then determines how much the community spouse may retain. In general, that amount is one-half of the combined total, subject to a minimum and a maximum that are adjusted annually. We will cover the calculation in more detail in a future post.
In addition to resource protections, the community spouse may be entitled to a portion of the institutionalized spouse's income if needed to meet living expenses. This protection, known as the Minimum Monthly Maintenance Needs Allowance (MMMNA), can be critical when the healthy spouse has limited income of his or her own.
What About Required Minimum Distributions?
Many retirees receive RMDs from their retirement accounts. The fact that an account is paying RMDs does not exempt it from Medicaid in New Jersey. Each distribution is generally counted as income when received, and the remaining account balance is counted as a resource.
Liquidating a retirement account to meet the resource limit can trigger significant income tax consequences. Anyone in this situation should consult an accountant in addition to an attorney before taking action.
The Five-Year Look-Back Period
One of the most common mistakes families make is giving away assets shortly before applying for Medicaid. New Jersey applies a five-year look-back period, during which Medicaid reviews transfers made for less than fair market value.
If Medicaid discovers gifts, transfers to children, or other below-market transfers during the look-back period, it may impose a penalty period. During that time, the applicant may be financially eligible but still unable to receive Medicaid benefits. The look-back applies not only to bank accounts but also to retirement assets and other property interests. Before transferring a retirement account, cashing out a 401(k), gifting IRA assets, or moving funds to family members, it is important to understand the potential consequences. Read more about the 5-Year Lookback here.
Asset Preservation Strategies
The good news is that Medicaid planning is not limited to giving assets away. Many lawful strategies can preserve assets while helping families prepare for future care needs. Depending on the circumstances, planning may include:
Creating irrevocable trusts well in advance of anticipated care needs
The most effective strategy is often early planning. When a family begins planning more than five years before long-term care is needed, significantly more options are usually available. Waiting until a health crisis arises often limits those options and increases financial risk.
The Bottom Line
Retirement accounts do not receive an exemption under New Jersey Medicaid rules. The account balance counts as a resource, and distributions from the account count as income.
An IRA, 401(k), 403(b), pension, annuity, or other retirement assets may affect eligibility differently depending on whether the applicant is single or married and whether distributions are being received. Because retirement assets can affect both the income and resource tests, careful planning is essential. The best time to address Medicaid planning is before a crisis occurs. Families who plan early often have significantly more opportunities to preserve assets, protect spouses, and qualify for the long-term care benefits they may eventually need.